Adrienne

Hey, I think I'm impacted by the same issue.
I've replaced the original fan of the HC4 with a Noctua NF-A4x10 5V PWM earlier this year. 
It was working as expected, but since couple weeks the fan is at 100% speed continuously, which is loud. 
It sounds like it's a software upgrade that broke the PWM control, but no idea which one.  
I've done part of the same testing you mentioned but didn't managed to find a fix neither. 
I'm probably even more beginner than you, so I don't think I can help much unfortunately.  
How can we get more eyes on this issue? Did you post on Odroid Forum? 
 
 

Board: ODROID HC4
Kernel: 6.12.42-current-meson64
Issue: PWM fan control completely non-functional despite software appearing to work
 
Problem Summary:
The HC4's PWM fan runs at constant speed regardless of PWM settings. Manual PWM control has zero effect on fan speed, even when setting PWM to 0 (fan should stop/slow) or 255 (full speed).
 
What I've Tried:
Hardware Testing:
Verified fan wiring with schematic (Pin 1=+5V, Pin 2=GND, Pin 3=TACHO, Pin 4=PWM) Tested with Noctua NF-A4x10 5V PWM fan (confirmed working on other systems) Swapped PWM/TACHO wire positions - no change  
Software Testing:
Manual PWM control: echo 0|50|255 > /sys/class/hwmon/hwmon2/pwm1 - no response Direct PWM chip control: /sys/class/pwm/pwmchip0/pwm0/ - no response Tested different PWM chips (pwmchip0, pwmchip1) and channels Stopped fancontrol service to avoid conflicts Verified PWM files exist and accept values  
Overlay Testing:
Tried existing Armbian overlays: meson-g12-pwm-gpiox-5-fan Copied PWM overlays from official ODROID Ubuntu image: fanspeed-full.dtbo, pwm_a-pwmfan.dtbo, etc. Overlays present in filesystem but show no loading errors or effects  
System Status:
PWM driver loaded: meson-pwm ff802000.pwm: using obsolete compatible PWM devices detected: /sys/class/pwm/pwmchip0, /sys/class/pwm/pwmchip1 Device tree shows: cat /proc/device-tree/pwm-fan/compatible = pwm-fan Fan gets power and runs, but zero PWM response  
Research Findings:
Found GitHub discussion showing HC4 PWM was broken in Armbian (August 2023 merge/revert cycle) where "PWM pulse reading was removed from HC4." This appears to be an ongoing regression in 6.x kernels.
Similar issue documented in forum post about ODROID C2 where user had PWM files working but "nothing happen" until they manually patched device tree.
 
What I Want to Contribute:
I'd like to properly fix HC4 PWM fan control and contribute the solution back to Armbian. This affects anyone wanting quiet operation or proper thermal management.
 
Need Guidance On:
I'm relatively new to device tree development and embedded Linux, but I'm motivated to learn and contribute a proper fix.
I'd appreciate guidance on:
Where to start - What's the best approach for a beginner to debug device tree PWM issues? Learning resources - Any recommended documentation for understanding Amlogic PWM/device tree development? Debugging methodology - How to compare current vs. working device tree for PWM routing? Development workflow - What tools should I learn for creating/testing HC4-specific overlays or patches? Contribution process - How do device tree fixes typically get submitted and reviewed in Armbian?